Evidence with integrity

I want IDM to earnwhat it claims.

I created IDM. That makes it my responsibility to be clear about its limits. The integrated framework has not been independently validated. Research on particular practices and ideas can inform a specific claim without proving IDM as a whole.

Explore the evidence map
What research may supportSpecific claims
Where the evidence stands
What remains openIDM as an integrated framework

Explore the evidence map

Examine a practice and its related literature.

Each connection is a claim to examine. Related research may be indirect, limited to certain groups, or focused on a different use or outcome; it does not prove IDM as a whole.

IDM practice

Observe and name the state

Related area of study or practiceAffect labeling

Studies of affect labeling examine what changes when an emotion is put into words. Naming a feeling may help someone examine it; that research does not establish IDM’s broader concept of an Organizing State.

Appears in

Emotion-regulation research · Mindfulness-based approaches

Responsible claim: these sources relate to this practice. Who was studied, how it was used, what changed, and the limits of the research still matter. IDM’s added value remains untested.

Three kinds of grounding

Not every source answers the same question.

Keeping these layers separate prevents scientific research, clinical tradition, and lived-experience wisdom from being treated as interchangeable.

01

External evidence

What research speaks to a specific claim?

Research may support a particular practice, process, use, or outcome related to IDM.

The language should match who and what was actually studied. Related research cannot validate IDM by association.
02

Clinical lineages

Which recognized approaches inform the clinical work?

IDM draws from CBT, DBT, ACT, mindfulness, attachment-informed care, parts-informed work, behavioral activation, and somatic practice.

Lineage explains influence. It is not evidence that IDM reproduces the outcomes of those approaches.
03

Conceptual influences

Which sources help describe lived experience?

Carl Jung and contemplative traditions helped shape IDM’s questions about awareness, tension, meaning, and integration.

Conceptual influence is not proof of clinical effectiveness. These ideas remain open to examination and correction.

The honest line

Related research is not the same as proof of IDM.

A source may support one practice or idea without validating the framework that brings several ideas together. The language used should match what was actually studied.

What IDM can responsibly say
  • Some practices and ideas within IDM are informed by named areas of research.
  • Its clinical and conceptual influences are identified.
  • Its ideas remain open to correction.
  • Its central questions can be studied.
What IDM cannot yet say
  • That IDM is a validated standalone treatment.
  • That its sequencing improves outcomes beyond its component parts.
  • That it is appropriate for every person, diagnosis, or clinical situation.
  • That contemplative or metaphysical claims are clinical science.

The research invitation

What would we need to study?

I welcome research and critique that could show where IDM contributes something useful, where it repeats existing work, where it falls short, or where it needs to change.

Research question

Does assessing what is shaping the moment, available capacity, and context improve how an intervention is received?

One possible approachCompare intervention reception with and without an explicit, collaborative organizing-pattern and capacity assessment.

Possible measuresSense of being understood · intervention receptivity · session alliance